Why this fingering suggestion for E locrian scale?
Why this Fingering Suggestion for E Locrian Scale?
Different Fingering Suggestions
When it comes to playing the E Locrian scale, there are various fingering suggestions that musicians may encounter. The choice of fingering can depend on factors such as the instrument being played and the specific technique employed. Let’s explore some of the different fingering options for the E Locrian scale.
The Source Book’s Fingering Recommendation
One fingering suggestion for the E Locrian scale comes from a book called “The Source.” In this book, the author recommends a specific fingering pattern: 212 3412 312 34123. This differs from the more commonly seen fingering pattern of 123 1234 123 12345. The question arises as to why the author of “The Source” suggests this particular fingering approach.
Common Fingering Patterns
The more commonly seen fingering pattern for scales, including the E Locrian scale, is 123 1234 123 12345. This fingering pattern is widely used and familiar to many musicians. It works well for the right hand in this particular scale. However, “The Source” book proposes a different fingering pattern.
Possible Reasons for the Different Fingering Suggestion
The reasons behind the different fingering suggestion in “The Source” book may involve technical considerations or a desire to offer a fresh perspective on playing the E Locrian scale. The author might have specific technical challenges in mind that can be better addressed by the suggested fingering pattern. Additionally, the author may have wanted to provide a unique approach to playing the scale, deviating from the more common fingering patterns.
The Subjectivity of Fingering Choices
It is important to note that the choice of fingering for scales is not always standardized or universally agreed upon. Different musicians and teachers may have their own preferences and approaches to fingering various scales. The fingering suggestion in “The Source” book represents one possible approach among many.
Conclusion
The fingering suggestion for the E Locrian scale can vary depending on the instrument and the specific technique being used. “The Source” book proposes a different fingering pattern (212 3412 312 34123) compared to the more commonly seen pattern (123 1234 123 12345). The reasons behind this different fingering suggestion may involve technical considerations or a desire to offer a fresh perspective on playing the scale. Ultimately, the choice of fingering for scales can be subjective, and musicians may explore different options to find what works best for them.
Sources:
- Music: Practice & Theory Stack Exchange. “Why this fingering suggestion for E locrian scale?” [Online]. Available: https://music.stackexchange.com/questions/101085/why-this-fingering-suggestion-for-e-locrian-scale
- Guitar Scale. “E Locrian bass guitar scale” [Online]. Available: https://www.guitarscale.org/bass/e-locrian.html
- Piano Marvel. “Fingering for Modes” [Online]. Available: https://pianomarvel.com/article/fingering-for-modes
FAQs
Why this Fingering Suggestion for E Locrian Scale?
What is the suggested fingering for the E Locrian scale in “The Source” book?
The suggested fingering for the E Locrian scale in “The Source” book is 212 3412 312 34123.
How does the suggested fingering differ from the more common fingering patterns?
The suggested fingering (212 3412 312 34123) differs from the more common fingering pattern of 123 1234 123 12345.
Why does “The Source” book propose a different fingering approach?
The reasons behind the different fingering suggestion in “The Source” book may involve technical considerations or a desire to offer a fresh perspective on playing the E Locrian scale.
Is the more common fingering pattern (123 1234 123 12345) still valid for the E Locrian scale?
Yes, the more common fingering pattern is still valid for the E Locrian scale. It is widely used and works well for the right hand in this particular scale.
Are there any benefits to using the suggested fingering (212 3412 312 34123) over the common fingering pattern?
The suggested fingering may have specific technical benefits or address certain challenges that the common fingering pattern does not. It offers a different approach and may provide a fresh perspective on playing the E Locrian scale.
Can musicians choose their own preferred fingering for the E Locrian scale?
Yes, musicians have the flexibility to choose their own preferred fingering for the E Locrian scale. Fingering choices can vary based on personal comfort, hand size, and playing style.
Are there any other alternative fingering suggestions for the E Locrian scale?
Yes, there can be alternative fingering suggestions for the E Locrian scale. Different musicians and teachers may propose their own preferred fingerings based on their experience and technical approach.
How important is fingering in playing scales like the E Locrian scale?
Fingering is an important aspect of playing scales as it affects the efficiency, accuracy, and fluidity of the performance. Choosing the right fingering can contribute to smoother execution and facilitate better control over the instrument.