The Harmonica Player on My Boy Lollipop: Unraveling the Debate
The song “My Boy Lollipop” has become an iconic piece of music history, known for its catchy melody and infectious ska rhythm. However, one aspect of the song that has remained a subject of debate and speculation is the identity of the harmonica player on Millie Small’s version of the track.
The Origins of “My Boy Lollipop”
The song “My Boy Lollipop” was originally written by Robert Spencer of the doo-wop group The Cadillacs and recorded by American singer Barbie Gaye in 1956 under the title “My Boy Lollypop” (Sheffield Forum). However, it was the 1964 rendition by Jamaican singer Millie Small that catapulted the song to international fame and introduced ska music to a global audience (Wikipedia).
The Harmonica Solo: A Unique Addition
In the original version of the song, a saxophone solo was featured. However, in Millie Small’s version, the saxophone solo was replaced by a harmonica solo, adding a unique twist to the composition (Steve Hoffman Music Forums).
The Urban Legend: Rod Stewart’s Involvement
Over the years, various names have been associated with the harmonica player credit, leading to a mix of speculation and urban legend. One of the early rumors suggested that Rod Stewart, renowned for his vocal and musical talents, played the harmonica on “My Boy Lollipop.” However, this claim has been debunked, as Rod Stewart himself has denied any involvement in the recording (Steve Hoffman Music Forums).
The Primary Candidates
Two primary candidates have emerged from the discussions regarding the harmonica player on Millie Small’s version of the song. The first is Pete Hogman, a member of the band The Five Dimensions. Pete Hogman, who now resides in Ryde on the Isle of Wight, has been credited by some sources as the harmonica player on “My Boy Lollipop” (Steve Hoffman Music Forums).
The second potential candidate is Jimmy Powell, another member of The Five Dimensions. Powell’s harmonica skills and his association with the band make him a plausible contender for the role (Steve Hoffman Music Forums).
Ernest Ranglin’s Contribution
While the debate surrounding the harmonica player continues, it is worth noting that the record’s arrangement is officially credited to Ernest Ranglin, a Jamaican guitarist renowned for his contributions to ska and reggae music (Steve Hoffman Music Forums). Ranglin’s guitar work on “My Boy Lollipop” adds to the vibrant sound of the track.
Conclusion
In conclusion, the identity of the harmonica player on Millie Small’s version of “My Boy Lollipop” remains a topic of speculation and ongoing discussion. While urban legend initially pointed to Rod Stewart, it is more likely that the harmonica solo was performed by either Pete Hogman or Jimmy Powell, both members of The Five Dimensions. Regardless of the unresolved mystery, “My Boy Lollipop” continues to be celebrated as a significant song in the history of ska music.
FAQs
Who originally wrote and recorded “My Boy Lollipop”?
The song “My Boy Lollipop” was originally written by Robert Spencer of the doo-wop group The Cadillacs. It was first recorded by American singer Barbie Gaye in 1956 under the title “My Boy Lollypop”.
Who recorded the popular version of “My Boy Lollipop”?
The popular version of “My Boy Lollipop” was recorded by Jamaican singer Millie Small in 1964. Her rendition became an international hit and played a significant role in introducing ska music to a global audience.
Why was the saxophone solo replaced with a harmonica solo in Millie Small’s version?
In Millie Small’s version of “My Boy Lollipop,” the original saxophone solo was replaced with a harmonica solo. This change was made to give the song a unique and distinct sound, incorporating elements of ska music.
Was Rod Stewart the harmonica player on “My Boy Lollipop”?
No, Rod Stewart was not the harmonica player on “My Boy Lollipop.” Despite early rumors and urban legends associating him with the song, Rod Stewart himself has denied any involvement in the recording.
Who are the possible candidates for the harmonica player on the song?
Two primary candidates have emerged from the discussions. They are Pete Hogman and Jimmy Powell, both members of the band The Five Dimensions. They have been credited by some sources as potential harmonica players on “My Boy Lollipop.”
Is there an official credit for the harmonica player on the record?
The official credit for the harmonica player on “My Boy Lollipop” remains uncertain. However, the arrangement of the record is credited to Ernest Ranglin, a Jamaican guitarist who also played guitar on the recording.
Why is the identity of the harmonica player still debated?
The identity of the harmonica player on “My Boy Lollipop” is still debated due to conflicting information and speculation. The lack of a definitive answer has contributed to ongoing discussions and the emergence of various theories.
What is the significance of “My Boy Lollipop” in music history?
“My Boy Lollipop” holds significance in music history as one of the first songs to introduce ska music to a global audience. It played a crucial role in popularizing the genre and remains a celebrated and iconic track to this day.