The Harmonica Player on My Boy Lollipop: Unraveling the Debate
The Mistaken Attribution to Rod Stewart
For many years, the harmonica solo on the hit song “My Boy Lollipop” by Millie Small was mistakenly credited to Rod Stewart. However, it is important to clarify that Rod Stewart himself has denied any involvement in playing the harmonica on the track. This attribution appears to have been a result of confusion or misinformation.
Possible Candidates for the Harmonica Player
While the true identity of the harmonica player remains a subject of speculation, there are two likely candidates associated with the recording of “My Boy Lollipop.” These candidates are Pete Hogman and Jimmy Powell, both members of the band The Five Dimensions during the time of the song’s release.
Pete Hogman’s Claim and Reputation
Pete Hogman, known for his contributions to The Pete Hogman Blues Band and Hoggie & The Sharpetones, has claimed to be the harmonica player on “My Boy Lollipop.” Although this claim has not been officially confirmed, Hogman is widely recognized for his talent as a harmonica player, which lends credibility to his assertion.
Debunking the Rod Stewart Rumor
Despite the persistent rumor associating Rod Stewart with the harmonica solo, there is no substantial evidence to support this claim. Through thorough research and analysis, it has been established that Stewart’s involvement in playing the harmonica on “My Boy Lollipop” is unfounded.
Ernest Ranglin’s Contribution and the Record’s Arrangement
Ernest Ranglin, an accomplished Jamaican guitarist and composer, is credited with arranging “My Boy Lollipop.” Ranglin, known for his significant contributions to Jamaican music styles such as ska and reggae, also played guitar on the recording. While Ranglin’s involvement is well-documented, it is important to note that he did not play the harmonica on the track.
The Live Studio Recording and Jon Hiseman’s Drumming
The recording of “My Boy Lollipop” featured a live studio performance, capturing the infectious energy and spontaneity of the musicians. Jon Hiseman, a highly respected and versatile drummer, played the drums on the track. Hiseman’s skillful drumming contributed to the rhythmic foundation of the song.
Conclusion
In conclusion, the harmonica player on “My Boy Lollipop” remains a subject of debate and speculation. While Pete Hogman and Jimmy Powell are the most likely candidates associated with the recording, Pete Hogman’s claim carries weight due to his reputation as a harmonica player. The attribution of the harmonica solo to Rod Stewart has been debunked, and Ernest Ranglin’s arrangement and guitar work are well-documented. The live studio recording captured the energetic performance, with Jon Hiseman providing the drumming. The true identity of the harmonica player may continue to be a mystery, but the impact of the harmonica solo on “My Boy Lollipop” remains undeniable.
Sources:
- Wikipedia contributors. (2021, December 30). My Boy Lollipop. In Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia. Retrieved from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/My_Boy_Lollipop
- Last.fm. (n.d.). Millie – My Boy Lollipop. Retrieved from https://www.last.fm/music/Millie/_/My+Boy+Lollipop/+wiki
- Steve Hoffman Music Forums. (n.d.). Harmonica player on My Boy Lollipop question. Retrieved from https://forums.stevehoffman.tv/threads/harmonica-player-on-my-boy-lollipop-question.127034/
FAQs
Who is credited with playing the harmonica on “My Boy Lollipop”?
The true identity of the harmonica player on “My Boy Lollipop” remains uncertain. While it is commonly attributed to Pete Hogman or Jimmy Powell of The Five Dimensions, no definitive confirmation has been made.
Was Rod Stewart the harmonica player on “My Boy Lollipop”?
No, Rod Stewart was not the harmonica player on “My Boy Lollipop.” Despite rumors suggesting his involvement, Rod Stewart himself has denied playing the harmonica on the song.
What is Pete Hogman’s claim regarding the harmonica solo?
Pete Hogman, a renowned harmonica player associated with The Pete Hogman Blues Band and Hoggie & The Sharpetones, has claimed to be the harmonica player on “My Boy Lollipop.” However, his claim has not been officially confirmed.
Who arranged the song “My Boy Lollipop”?
The arrangement of “My Boy Lollipop” is credited to Ernest Ranglin, a Jamaican guitarist and composer. Ranglin is known for his contributions to Jamaican music styles, including ska and reggae.
Was the recording of “My Boy Lollipop” performed live in the studio?
Yes, the backing track for “My Boy Lollipop” was recorded live in the studio. This approach captured the energy and spontaneity of the musicians, contributing to the vibrant and lively character of the song.
Who played the drums on “My Boy Lollipop”?
The drums on the recording of “My Boy Lollipop” were played by Jon Hiseman, a highly respected and versatile drummer known for his work in various genres, including rock, jazz, and blues.
Why was the harmonica player on “My Boy Lollipop” a subject of debate?
The identity of the harmonica player on “My Boy Lollipop” became a subject of debate due to conflicting claims and rumors. Several individuals, including Pete Hogman and Jimmy Powell, have been associated with the harmonica solo, but no definitive answer has been established.
Is there any evidence supporting the claim that Rod Stewart played the harmonica on “My Boy Lollipop”?
No credible evidence supports the claim that Rod Stewart played the harmonica on “My Boy Lollipop.” Thorough research and analysis have debunked this rumor, and Rod Stewart himself has denied any involvement in playing the harmonica on the song.